8924 North Seneca St. Weedsport, NY 13166     (315) 834-6641

What Are People Saying About Old Erie?

Excerpts from Syracuse.com - Dining Forum

~ Owner's name is Ted Tomandl. Worked at Rosalie's. Like others before him, he brought his experience with him and is doing it right.

~ Went there on a Friday night and the food was wonderful. Some changes to the menu but nothing wholesale. Overall the service was great and food excellent.

~ Went to this place for a wedding rehearsal dinner. Had poor expectations ahead of time, but was quickly impressed by how good everything was. I definitely recommend it!

~ In town on business and the Old Erie was recommended by the motel front desk. Went for the Turkey Wrap with bacon and avocado on the menu in the lobby. EXTREMELY surprised by the German dinner menu and very much enjoyed pirogues and Beef a la Deutsche! Will definitely be back someday.

~ Some regulars (guess why they're regulars) have told us that no place has both the hospitality and the food that matches the Old Erie. Teddy's the best !

~ Jill from south Florida says: There is no better restaurant experience between here and Florida that I have stopped at! Excellent is not a good enough word!

~ I stopped by after the Jordan fest (great car show) a couple of Sundays ago. From a restaurant owner's perspective, It was very good.

~ Great! Thanks! I'll look forward to going back soon. ~ I think their new menu resembles ... Dominick's.

From Tripadvisor.com

~ Our food was delicious and innovative, and the service was excellent.

~ The only disappointment was that we had no room left for dessert.

~ The service was attentive and the prices very reasonable.

~ Staff very good.

~ The portions are very generous.

More Kudos...

~ Hi I am from Indiana, My friend and I stopped on our way from Maine. I can't tell you how much we enjoyed our meal we had the Mix grill. Derek was our waiter and did a wonderful job. Wish I could copy the Portabello mushroom with spinach Yum!!!! My compliments to the chef. Thank you again, Jeri A.

~ I just wanted to let you know that it passed every expectation of all the ladies -- and we are not shy, picky eaters! I haven't heard that many exclamations of "such a great meal" since Becco's in NYC 5 years back!! And when the meal was finished (oh the desserts ... and the service was A+) -- we enjoyed your patio for another 35 minutes with a couple of drinks and many laughs. Thanks for an outstanding brunch today - it was top notch. Hope you can get the word out via some outdoor banners, Email lists and/or press releases so the place will be full on Sundays. The food is the best brunch food around. We'll be back! - Lisa K.

~ Beth and Ted, your meal preparations for my wife's office and our holiday home party were received very well. The girls at the office all wanted to know where the food came from and everything was also a hit at our home. The girl who helped set this all up was very accommodating and very nice. ... have a nice New Year and thank you, - Bill E.

~ Myself and a group of 8 women had dinner at your restaurant this evening (6:30, WWOTT reservation, Lori was our server). We have had dinner as a group for the past 12+ years, monthly all over the area. Several weeks ago I started telling them about the meal my husband and I had eaten at your place back in April ... needless to say the choice of restaurants for July was selected! We shall return -- 2 members of our group were not able to be with us this evening and know what they missed -- great food, great service, small hit on your wallet. Thank you very much for tonight. Joan B. - WWOTT (Wild Women On The Town!)

~ Ted & Beth, Thought I'd try the high tech way to reach you. We enjoyed our dinner last Thursday. Keep up the good work. Best Regards - Mike and Linda G.

~ Thank you so much for the excellent food and service for my parents 50th wedding anniversary party. Lisa did a wonderful job serving and helping us with the details. I really appreciate all of your efforts. The food was unbelievable and definitely exceeded my expectations. Everything was prepared perfectly. The Stuffing was the best I have ever had! - Sincerely, Karen T., Lake Mary Florida